- Julie Barris | Crisis Counselor | Therapist-in-Training
- Aug 12
Sometimes, calm feels uncomfortable because your nervous system is wired to expect chaos. When you've lived in survival mode for so long, peace can feel unfamiliar—even unsafe.

You finally get what you thought you always wanted: a stable partner, a calm home, no fighting, no drama. Everything is... fine. So why do you feel so unsettled?
Why do you want to pick a fight just to feel something?Why does "normal" feel boring—or even suffocating?
If this sounds familiar, you're not broken. You're not ungrateful. You're just experiencing the psychological residue of what many people carry quietly through life: a nervous system conditioned for chaos.
When “Calm” Doesn’t Feel Safe
For people who grew up in homes full of emotional unpredictability—whether it was conflict, silence, neglect, or criticism—calm wasn't comfort, it was the calm before the storm. Your body learned to anticipate emotional whiplash, to stay on alert, to expect the shift.
So now, when things are peaceful? It doesn’t feel safe. It feels suspicious.
This is what psychologists refer to as a dysregulated baseline—when your internal state of “normal” has been set to high-alert. As adults, this can show up in relationships as restlessness, mistrust, self-sabotage, or even craving conflict to feel close. In short, we confuse peace with disconnection, and chaos with love.
The Love–Chaos Confusion
Here’s where it gets trickier: many of us learned to associate chaotic relationships with deep emotion. When you were a child and your parent’s love came inconsistently—only when you were pleasing them, or after yelling, or not at all—your brain started to link intensity with connection.
So now, when someone shows up with calm, secure love, it may feel... empty. Your system doesn’t recognize it as real, because it’s never been your emotional blueprint.
This is how people end up in painful cycles—gravitating toward volatile relationships, mistaking anxiety for passion, and overlooking safe partners who “don’t feel like home.”
How to Unlearn Chaos as Love
1. Stop judging your reaction. Start getting curious.
You’re not sabotaging your happiness—you’re responding to what your body believes is “normal.” Be gentle with yourself as you learn a new emotional language.
2. Learn what safety actually feels like.
Safety is consistent, respectful, and kind. It’s not adrenaline, high-stakes drama, or begging to be heard. It might feel boring at first, but that’s because your nervous system is recalibrating. Let it.
3. Name the discomfort when it shows up.
Say to yourself, “This is what peace feels like—and it’s okay that it feels unfamiliar.” Naming it builds awareness and choice.
4. Practice staying.
When the urge to pull away, shut down, or focus on what's wrong shows up—pause. Take a breath. Gently ask yourself, “What feelings might be underneath this moment, if I gave them space?”
5. Build new associations.
Over time, you can teach your body to associate calm with connection. Seek out small, safe moments—shared meals, quiet laughs, steady support—and remind yourself: this is love too.
Relearning peace is not the absence of feeling. It’s the rebuilding of trust—in yourself, and in the world around you.
And it’s okay if it takes time.
So here’s the question worth asking yourself:
If love doesn’t have to look like chaos, then... what might it look like instead?
More Related Articles:
When Enough Is Enough: Why Knowing Your Limits Is the Most Underrated Form of Self-Care
Anxiety Isn’t the Enemy—It’s a Messenger: 5 Surprisingly Simple Steps to Manage Daily Overwhelm
Your Nervous System Misses the Forest: When Was the Last Time You Touched a Tree?
I Lost My Job and Found Myself: A Story of Growth After Unemployment
How to Gently Work Through What Might Be Getting in the Way of Your Therapy