top of page

FOLLOW US

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Threads
  • LinkedIn
  • Writer: Julie Barris | Crisis Counselor | Therapist-in-Training
    Julie Barris | Crisis Counselor | Therapist-in-Training
  • Oct 25

Why we push away the people we crave most often comes down to fear disguised as protection. When love feels too close to the pain we once knew, our hearts confuse safety with danger—and we push away the very people who make us feel most alive.

ree

Got 5 minutes? Join countless listeners who are exploring this powerful topic — listen here.

The Tug-of-War Within: Why We Push Away the People We Crave Most

You know that feeling—wanting someone to come close, yet flinching the second they do? It’s like your heart is stepping on the gas and the brakes at the same time. One part of you aches for connection, while another part screams, “Back off before it hurts!”


This inner tug-of-war is called approach-avoidance conflict, and it’s one of the most confusing emotional experiences a person can face—especially in close relationships.


The Push and Pull of the Heart


When you experience approach-avoidance conflict, your emotions are caught between two competing needs: the need for safety and the need for intimacy. One moment, you’re desperate for closeness; the next, you feel suffocated by it. This pattern can leave you questioning your feelings, your partner, and even your sanity. Understanding this dynamic isn’t about blaming yourself—it’s about realizing your brain is still trying to protect you from an old danger that no longer exists. Recognizing that is the first step toward breaking free from the cycle.


When Love Feels Like a Threat


For many people who’ve lived through neglect, abuse, or emotional inconsistency growing up, love can feel both magnetic and terrifying. As children, we learned that affection often came with conditions or danger—that the same hands that offered comfort could also cause pain.


So as adults, our brains get mixed up. We crave closeness because that’s how humans are wired, but our nervous system remembers the hurt and tries to protect us by pushing people away.


We might say things like,


  • “I just need space,” when we actually want to be held.

  • “They don’t really care,” when they’ve been trying their best.

  • Or, “I’m done with this,” when what we really mean is, “Please, don’t give up on me.”


It’s not manipulation—it’s survival.


The Hidden Cost of Staying Torn


Living in that constant emotional back-and-forth is exhausting. You start doubting yourself, your partner, even your own feelings. One moment you feel desperate for connection; the next, you’re cold, distant, or furious for being “invaded.”


This cycle doesn’t just strain relationships—it erodes self-trust. You start believing there’s something wrong with you, when in reality, your mind is just trying to protect an old wound with outdated tools.


Healing the Inner Conflict


Healing approach-avoidance conflict starts with noticing what’s happening—without shame. It means pausing long enough to recognize when your fear is taking the wheel. It means reminding yourself: “I’m safe now. This isn’t the past.”


Therapy, self-compassion, and open communication with loved ones can gradually retrain your nervous system to understand that closeness isn’t dangerous anymore. And when you start feeling safe enough to let love in—even just a little—you begin to rewrite the story your trauma once told.


Eye-opening question: If love itself isn’t what hurts us—but the fear of losing it—what might happen if, for once, you stopped running and simply let yourself be loved?


💬 Ready to start your own healing journey?


Book a session with one of our compassionate therapists at Moody Melon Counseling. We’re here when you’re ready. 🍉


More Related Articles:

  • Writer: Julie Barris | Crisis Counselor | Therapist-in-Training
    Julie Barris | Crisis Counselor | Therapist-in-Training
  • Dec 29, 2024

The hidden dangers of isolation often go unnoticed, quietly eroding both our mental health and relationships as we retreat into solitude to protect ourselves from emotional pain. While isolation may offer temporary relief, it ultimately deepens the wounds we try to avoid, making it harder to heal and reconnect with the world around us.

The Hidden Dangers of Isolation: Are You Really Protecting Yourself, or Are You Just Hiding?

In a world that demands constant connection, the act of isolating oneself might seem like an unexpected choice. Yet, many people find themselves retreating into solitude during times of stress, trauma, or emotional overwhelm. Whether it's an unhealthy habit or a temporary coping mechanism, isolation often becomes a form of self-protection. But what if, in an attempt to shield ourselves from pain, we’re actually causing more harm than good?


Why We Isolate: The Psychological Defense Mechanism


When life becomes too overwhelming—whether due to a traumatic event, work burnout, or a personal loss—it’s tempting to turn inward. It feels safer to retreat from the world, to wall off our emotions, and to avoid the judgment or misunderstanding we might encounter from others.


This tendency is not accidental; it's rooted in the way our brains process threat. In times of emotional distress, the desire for isolation can trigger the body's natural defense system. The idea is simple: protect yourself from further hurt by cutting off interaction with others. But while isolation may offer temporary relief, it doesn’t address the root of the problem.


The Cost of Isolation


While it may feel like self-care, prolonged isolation can have devastating consequences for mental health. Research has shown that social isolation can lead to increased risks of anxiety, depression, and even chronic physical health problems.


Here’s how isolation silently damages us:


  1. Increased Anxiety: The more we isolate, the more our anxiety increases. Our minds begin to fill in the gaps with worst-case scenarios, leading to heightened feelings of fear, panic, and dread.


  2. Depression: As we distance ourselves from others, we lose the support systems that help us process emotions and share our burdens. This lack of social connection can exacerbate feelings of sadness and hopelessness.


  3. Stagnant Growth: Isolation stunts emotional growth. We stop confronting our fears, challenges, and emotions, choosing instead to numb ourselves to them. Without social interaction, we miss opportunities to heal through conversation, understanding, and support.


  4. Loss of Perspective: When we are alone with our thoughts, it’s easy to distort reality. We begin to see ourselves as unworthy, unlovable, or hopeless—ideas that may not reflect the truth but are magnified by our isolation.


  5. Physical Health Decline: Chronic isolation has been linked to weakened immune function, increased blood pressure, and higher levels of inflammation. The mind-body connection is real: when our mental health suffers, our physical health follows suit.


Isolating From a Caring Partner: A Double Burden


Perhaps one of the most heartbreaking forms of isolation happens when we begin to pull away from a partner who cares deeply for us. Whether it’s a romantic partner, spouse, or long-time friend, the person who would naturally be our closest ally often ends up feeling like the enemy.


Why does this happen?


  • Fear of Burdening Others: When you're struggling emotionally, the instinct to protect your loved ones can cause you to shut them out. You may feel that by opening up, you're placing an additional burden on someone who already has their own problems to deal with. You don’t want to add to their stress, so you retreat, hoping to handle it alone.


  • Self-Doubt and Shame: Isolation can stem from feelings of unworthiness or shame. If you’re experiencing emotional turmoil, you might fear your partner will view you as weak or damaged. Instead of seeking comfort, you distance yourself, believing it’s better to be alone than to risk feeling judged.


  • Perceived Rejection: Sometimes, isolation from a partner occurs when you feel misunderstood or rejected, even if that’s not their intention. Your partner may have no idea that you’re hurting, and the distance grows as you stop communicating, feeding a cycle of emotional withdrawal.


  • Miscommunication: When one partner is emotionally distant or withdrawn, the other may not know how to respond. What could be an opportunity for connection quickly turns into a misunderstanding. This gap can cause hurt feelings on both sides and deepen the isolation.


The irony of isolating from a caring partner is that, in trying to protect yourself from feeling more vulnerable, you might inadvertently damage the relationship. The person who would want to help, listen, or offer support may end up feeling helpless, frustrated, or rejected.


The Cost of Isolating From a Partner


When we close off from someone who cares for us, we miss out on the very thing that could help us heal. Partners can offer emotional support, different perspectives, and encouragement to push through difficult times.


However, prolonged isolation from a partner can lead to:


  • Erosion of Trust: If your partner is unsure of what’s happening but feels excluded or shut out, trust can begin to erode. You may unintentionally create a distance that becomes hard to bridge.


  • Emotional Exhaustion for Both Partners: Even if your partner doesn’t overtly pressure you to open up, the strain of feeling like they’re walking on eggshells, unsure of how to help, can create a quiet emotional burden on both sides.


  • Deeper Emotional Disconnect: If isolation persists, it can lead to an emotional disconnect, where both partners feel distant, misunderstood, and disconnected—not just from each other, but also from themselves.


Breaking the Isolation: Steps Toward Reconnection


Recognizing the signs of isolation is the first step toward breaking free from its grip. But how do you actually begin to reconnect with the world around you? The good news is, it’s not an impossible task—it simply takes intention, vulnerability, and patience.


Here are some strategies for rebuilding your social connections—and restoring your relationship with your partner:


  1. Start Small: Reaching out to your partner may feel daunting, but don’t overwhelm yourself with expectations. Start by having small, honest conversations. Acknowledge that you’re struggling and let them know it’s not about them, but about you needing time and space to process.


  2. Be Honest About Your Needs: While it’s tempting to pull away, being upfront with your partner about what you need can actually deepen the connection. Do you need space, or do you just need someone to listen? Do you want help solving the problem, or would you rather just vent? Clear communication is key.


  3. Practice Vulnerability Together: Vulnerability isn’t just about opening up emotionally—it’s about allowing your partner to see and support you. Vulnerability can help both of you navigate difficult emotions and begin to understand each other better. This mutual sharing fosters deeper emotional intimacy.


  4. Seek Professional Help as a Couple: Sometimes, isolation is a response to deeper relationship issues. Seeking couples therapy can help both partners understand the roots of the isolation and work toward healthier communication patterns.


  5. Take Responsibility for Your Actions: If you’ve isolated yourself, it’s important to acknowledge how this behavior may have impacted your partner. Apologizing for the emotional distance and expressing gratitude for their patience can help rebuild trust.


Isolating for Protection, or Hiding from Growth?


Isolation can feel safe. It offers an escape from the chaos of life, from judgment, and from confrontation. But at what cost? Are you truly protecting yourself, or are you simply hiding from the possibility of growth, healing, and connection?


Isolating from your partner, someone who genuinely cares for you, may offer a false sense of security. But over time, it creates a silent divide that erodes trust and emotional intimacy. The longer we stay isolated, the harder it becomes to step out of our self-imposed prison. But the truth is, you are not alone in your struggles. There are others who understand, who care, and who want to help you grow through your pain.


So, what’s stopping you from reaching out? What’s one small step you can take today to break free from the walls you’ve built around yourself and your relationship?


The first step toward connection is often the hardest, but it’s also the most rewarding. Are you ready to rebuild your bonds, not just with others, but with yourself?


The question remains: Are you truly protecting yourself by isolating, or are you just hiding from the healing you deserve?


More Related Articles:

bottom of page